You’ve
worked hard all your
life to accumulate a
little personal wealth
and, sadly, just one
frivolous lawsuit could
wipe it all out.
In
today’s litigious culture,
a good number of people
have to take steps
to protect their assets
from lawsuits and illegitimate
creditor claims.
The
good news is, you don’t
have to be extremely
rich to take some action.
There
are some steps you
can take which include
ensuring that you have
enough liability coverage
on your homeowners’
and auto insurance
policies, and purchasing
an umbrella policy
providing additional
coverage above the
limits on your primary
policies.
But
you shouldn’t wait
until trouble is at
your door to take action.
If you do, trying to
protect your assets
from a claim would
do more harm than good.
Michael
Busch, a certified
financial planner,
said “It is imperative
that asset protection
strategies be implemented
before there is a problem,”
Busch said. “Once a
creditor has a claim
or is likely to have
a claim, any subsequent
transfer may be deemed
fraudulent. If a court
believes a transfer
was made with the intent
to defraud legitimate
creditors, the transfer
will not be upheld.”
Protecting
your personal assets
from litigation can
become quite complicated.
So, if you have a lot
to protect, it’s strongly
advised that you should
hire a lawyer and financial
adviser.
But
before doing so, you
need to be sure that
you have enough assets
to make the effort
worthwhile.
“Most
people, if they don’t
have a sizable portfolio
or net worth to protect,
it’s not feasible to
take the extra steps
to protect it,” Busch
said. “Generally, someone’s
not going to bother
filing a lawsuit against
someone who they know
has few assets.”
Let’s
begin with the basics.
If
you own a home, your
homeowners’ insurance
protects you against
financial loss if you’re
found responsible for
someone injured on
your property or for
property damage. Your
auto insurance will
do the same thing in
relation to your automobiles.
Liability insurance
will pay for bodily
injury, property damage
and some additional
expenses of other drivers,
their passengers and
your passengers should
you or a driver covered
by your policy causes
an accident.
However,
liability insurance
doesn’t pay for damage
to your own vehicle.
So, if you want more
liability coverage
than provided by your
primary insurance policies,
you can buy a separate
personal umbrella policy.
Umbrella
coverage applies only
to losses over a large
dollar amount, but
the terms of coverage
are at times broader
than those of underlying
policies. Because umbrella
policies vary, you
should ensure that
the insurance agent
or company fully explains
the coverage.
You
have some built-in
protection under the
law. Wages may be garnished
only to pay child support,
back taxes and defaulted
student loans, while
retirement plans, such
as individual retirement
accounts, 401(k)s,
403(b)s, profit-sharing
plans and pensions
can’t be seized by
creditors. Creditors
are also unable to
seize the cash value
of a life insurance
policy or death benefits
from the policy.
Mr.
Busch said if you’re
worried about future
litigation, you could
always use part of
your money to pay down
your mortgage. Doing
so transfers your money
into the protected
asset, i.e., your home.
“If you had that same
money in a bank account,
a lawsuit could get
to it, but if it’s
in your house, it’s
protected,” he said.
“You’re taking exposed
assets and converting
them into assets that
are creditor-protected.”
You
should consult an attorney
for more complicated
financial situations.
This is especially
true if you’re already
in financial trouble.
“If
you’re already in financial
trouble, there is no
surefire method to
protect your assets
from rightful creditor
claims,” said Bill
Wallander, a partner
at Vinson & Elkins LLP in Dallas. “In that situation, it’s a matter of whether you can restructure
things with your creditors
through negotiations,
and if you can’t restructure
your financial challenges
with creditors, then
the individual needs
to consider whether
bankruptcy is appropriate
solution.”
Bear
in mind that the new
bankruptcy law, which
will become effective
in October, will make
it harder to file for
bankruptcy.
“If
you know that you’re
already insolvent or
if you’ve already been
sued and you start
to take steps to protect
your assets — transfer
your assets into a
trust or family partnership
or try to convert your
assets into exempt
property — that may
raise questions as
to your intent ,” Wallander
said.
Beyond
homeowners’ and auto
insurance, here are
three general scenarios
of consumers and what
they can do to protect
themselves.
If
you reside in an apartment,
you should consider
renters’ insurance.
There are several benefits
to renters’ insurance.
First,
a landlord’s insurance
will not cover a renter’s
personal property.
Second, having renters’
insurance will cover
your belongings and
pay you extra living
expenses if a fire
or other disaster forces
you to move temporarily
from your rented home.
Renter’s
insurance also provides
liability protection.
Should someone slips
and falls in your apartment
and sustains a serious
injury, he could sue
you for financial damages.
Policies
for renters’ insurance
vary, so be sure to
inquire with the insurance
company about liability
limits.
It
should be noted that
a young apartment dweller
that doesn’t have much
in the way of assets
probably doesn’t need
an umbrella policy.
For
a small-business owner,
“The structure of the
entity is going to
be the solution,” said
Michael Wald, an estate
planning lawyer in
Texas. What is needed
to be done is to separate
your personal assets
from the assets of
your business. That
can be accomplished
by how your company
is set up under the
law.
“They
ought to think about
making sure they incorporate
their business and
put in an entity that’s
creditor-protected
like a C corporation
and an S corporation,”
Busch said.
In
those two corporate
structures, shareholders
have limited liability
and can only lose what
they’ve invested in
the business, while
personal assets aren’t
subject to liability.
This contrasts sharply
with a sole proprietorship
structure which leaves
you wide open because
the owner has unlimited
personal liability
for all business’ debts.
“You’re
indistinguishable from
your business, so they
can go after your personal
assets and business
assets,” Busch said.
Anyone
who is in the latter
situation would be
well advised to keep
their umbrella liability
policy up to date.
A
controversial tool
is the family limited
partnership (FLP) A
family limited partnership
offers extra asset
protection to wealthy
families. The FLP is
a separate legal entity
requiring its own tax
return.
“In
the typical scenario,
family savings, investments
and titles to business
and real estate interests
are transferred into
the FLP, which if properly
structured, protects
those assets from potential
claims and lawsuits,”
said California attorney
Robert J. Mintz.
But
the IRS, which has
recently won a series
of court cases involving
FLPs, say they’re tax-avoidance
tools.
The
most recent case involved
a family limited partnership
of Texas millionaire
Albert Strangi.
The
U.S. Court of Appeals
for the 5th Circuit
affirmed an earlier
tax court ruling that
found that assets transferred
into the partnership
should be included
in Strangi’s estate
and thereby are subject
to estate taxes.
However,
Wald said that family
limited partnerships
are still a valid asset-protection
tool. However, they
must be more carefully
constructed.
“
… go to great lengths
to make sure that you
form it (properly)
and that you operate
it as an FLP. You certainly
can’t treat it as your
own bank account,”
said Wald.
If
you would like more
information regarding
asset protection, trusts,
family limited partnerships
or the subject of this
article please call
or email our office.